Universal HealthcareBy NextBestFit

Wind down the private health insurers

Years 1–5 · State insurance commissioners; NAIC; UHADiscuss this step
← All costs for this step

Insurer & plan overhead eliminated

The 'net cost of health insurance': premiums minus benefits. It is what private insurers, Medicare Advantage and Part D plans, and Medicaid managed-care plans keep for administration and profit.

Result
−$279.6B
$306.0B → $26.4B
Per resident, per year
−$820
÷ 341.1M people
Per household
−$2,115
÷ 132.2M households

How it's calculated

#StepArithmeticValue
1
Private health insurers' non-medical spending (CMS)
$176.5B
2
of which: profit (estimate)
$42.0B
3
of which: broker commissions & marketing (estimate)
$32.0B
4
of which: state premium taxes (estimate)
$18.0B
5
of which: claims processing, utilization management, networks, IT, salaries
$176.5B − $42.0B − $32.0B − $18.0B$84.5B
6
Medicare Advantage & Part D plan overhead (CMS)
$57.6B
7
Medicaid managed-care plan overhead (CMS)
$45.5B
8
Workers' comp & other programs' overhead (continues)
$26.4B
9
Net cost of insurance, 2024
$306.0B
10
Net cost of insurance under the plan
$26.4B
11
Eliminated
$26.4B − $306.0B−$279.6B

Inputs used

InputKindValue
Private health insurer profit (underwriting + fees)estimate, low confidence$42.0B
Broker & agent commissions and marketingestimate, low confidence$32.0B
State premium taxes paid by health insurersestimate, low confidence$18.0B
Trade-off: The largest administrative saving, paid for by insurer shutdowns, about 365,000 insurer jobs, and lost services some people value (care management, plan choice).